The BFG Long Trails hit 55k and had to go. So I researched for an extended time online and decided to go with Pirelli Scorpion ATRs from my local Discount Tire. I drive 80 highway miles a day to work, and then need something that can handle construction site mud, clay, and sugar sand when I get there. The Pirelli seems to offer a street biased all terrain tire, which is perfect for me. I have a '07 SE that came with 265/70/16's. I upgraded this time to 265/75/16, so roughly a 1" increase. They fit great, no rubbing. They are an E rated tire so they are pretty stiff. Good side is the sidewall flex during cornering is gone and you can really feel the road. Bad side (wifes opinion) is you can really feel the road, rides more like a truck now, but is in no way harsh or jarring. I personally like the change, to compare it to a car; it's like going from a touring tire to a low profile performance tire. The performance tire is stiffer and provides more response to the driver. These tire are very quiet at any speed, I don't believe they are any louder than the old tires they are replacing. These are brand new, so no real off road info to provide yet, but they handle great on the highway. I'll post an update down the road if you guys want. Here's a couple links to flickr for picks, I can't figure out how to imbed them here.