I'm not sure about a consensus, but the 1/2" VHB is working for me so far, but I probably bought it in 2011 and didn't get around to sticking the plastic covers back on until earlier this year, almost 5 years later. Ask me again after a full Winter
I'd be a little concerned Gorilla Glue would expand too much, and I'm not sure about the expansion qualities of liquid nails, but either of those might be fine if they are acceptable for the temperature ranges. Also at the time I think I looked into the 3M 3614 and went with VHB, but I'm not sure why at this point - more "stickiness?"