Thanks OPF, from Carl's
rear deflector thread I was surprised that about a 1.5 mpg fuel comsumption increase was seen. I think that roof top add-ons give a couple of different negative results, one from their added size but also from changing the size and shape of the drag area at the back of the vehicle.
As an aside I wonder how much the rear mud flaps affect the size of the rear drag area of the PF.

I don't recall seeing huge mudflaps on aerodynamic vehicles.
.